Ripple vs. SEC: Will the Legal Battle Finally End?

SEC Lawsuit Against Ripple

In December 2020, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filed a lawsuit against Ripple Labs, the company behind the XRP cryptocurrency. According to the SEC, Ripple sold unregistered securities and illegally raised $1.8 billion through the sale of XRP tokens. 

The Ripple/SEC lawsuit has become one of the most significant conflicts between a cryptocurrency company and regulatory authorities. After more than a year of court hearings and motions, the case seems to be reaching a critical juncture. This article will explore the latest Ripple/SEC lawsuit developments and discuss the possible outcomes.

‍

Ripple's Optimism and Legal Victories

Ripple has expressed confidence in its position despite the complexities of the legal battle. Stuart Alderoty, Ripple's Chief Legal Officer, shared the company's expectation that it would win the case against the SEC. Alderoty pointed out that the SEC had lost four out of its last five cases in the Supreme Court, suggesting that Ripple had a strong chance of prevailing in the lawsuit.

Additionally, Ripple has achieved significant victories in the courtroom, strengthening its defense. The court denied the SEC's request to access Ripple executives' personal financial records, ruling it irrelevant and intrusive. In its arguments, the SEC claimed that these records could provide evidence of XRP executives' financial motives. However, the court found this request to be irrelevant and excessively intrusive, marking another win for Ripple.

Furthermore, the court confirmed Ripple's argument that the SEC failed to give fair notice that XRP's sale was a securities transaction. Ultimately, this decision may undermine the SEC's case. In particular, it argues that the SEC failed to adequately clarify the status of cryptocurrencies, resulting in regulatory grey areas for companies like Ripple.

Another notable win was when Judge Sarah Netburn granted Ripple access to the SEC's internal communications about Bitcoin and Ethereum. This move could shed light on the SEC's process of distinguishing securities from currencies, a crucial factor in the case.

‍

The Hinman Documents and SEC's Handling of Speech

A significant development in the Ripple-SEC lawsuit was the release of documents related to former SEC director William Hinman's 2018 speech. The documents revealed internal discussions within the SEC before Hinman stated that Ethereum was not a security. This revelation raised questions about the credibility of the SEC's position and the potential impact on the lawsuit.

In response to the release of the Hinman documents, Ripple called for an investigation into the SEC's handling of Hinman's speech. The company argued that the documents undermined the SEC lawyers' argument that the speech was solely Hinman's opinion and not official guidance. Ripple's move suggests a strategic attempt to challenge the SEC's credibility and strengthen its position in the lawsuit.

‍

Prospects for Settlement and Final Ruling

Ripple CEO Brad Garlinghouse has expressed optimism about a resolution to the lawsuit in 2023, according to a CNBC report. However, he emphasized that a settlement would require clarity on classifying XRP as a security. The SEC's view that most cryptocurrencies are securities leaves little room for a settlement, according to Garlinghouse. 

However, according to XRP lawyer John Deaton, the SEC has less than a 3% chance of winning against Ripple outright as the long-running lawsuit nears its end. Deaton predicts that Judge Torres will make a final decision on the rollercoaster lawsuit filed by the SEC by Sept. 30 this year. He called attention to a "six-month list" that district judges must submit to Congress. The list includes all summary judgments pending for more than six months. 

Further, Former lawyer and SEC official Marc Fagel expressed doubts about the likelihood of a settlement, noting that it would probably have happened earlier if one were to occur. Further, Fagel noted that the impact of an injunction on future XRP sales remains controversial.

‍

Potential Ripple Effect on Global Cryptocurrencies

The Ripple-SEC lawsuit has entered its third calendar year, and the case seems to be approaching its resolution. Ripple has achieved significant legal victories and remains optimistic about its chances of prevailing against the SEC's claims. The release of the Hinman documents has raised questions about the SEC's handling of the case and its credibility. 

The final result of the Ripple lawsuit could reverberate through the crypto market worldwide. Having a favorable legal outcome for Ripple could set an important legal precedent for other cryptocurrencies. It may lead to a rapid surge in crypto innovations and market activity. 

In addition, the factors may result in a significant bull run for all holders of XRP tokens. It is estimated that the XRP price could reach its previous all-time high of $3.84 within hours of the court decision. In contrast, the most optimistic token holders expect the XRP coin to reach $21 by mid-2023 or early 2024, bringing investors huge returns. Ripple (XRP) is currently trading at $0.4896, up 1.32% in 24 hours, according to CoinMarketCap.